About this episode
What if the partners and suppliers who help a company grow could share in its upside? On episode 12 of The Tesla Pod, host Irosha de Silva rides through San Francisco on Full Self-Driving with Duane Good, cofounder and CEO of Wrnt.
Wrnt is building the operating system for stock warrants: issuing them, tracking them and managing them over their whole life. Warrants show up in venture debt, strategic partnerships and commercial deals, yet many companies still track them in spreadsheets and piece them back together at audit time. Duane spent a long career in financial services before founding Wrnt in January 2025, and he makes the case that warrants could become the standard way a strategic partner gets rewarded for helping a company grow.
What they get into
- What a stock warrant is, in plain English
- Why warrant programs end up rebuilt at audit
- Warrants as the way partners and suppliers share in the upside
- What a warrant is actually worth to each side
- Dilution, and how founders should think about it
- Lessons from a long career in financial services
- Building Wrnt and what comes next
For founders weighing a big partnership, finance teams who inherit warrant spreadsheets, and anyone curious how a supplier can share in a startup's upside.
The passenger
About Wrnt
The operating system for stock warrants: set up, issue and manage warrants so the partners and suppliers who help a company grow can share in its upside.
The insights
Employees get stock options. The partners who help you grow usually get only cash. The write-up pulls out the big idea, the numbers, the counterargument and what it means for the autonomous future.
Transcript
Auto-generated from the episode audio and lightly cleaned up, so expect the odd misheard word. Each timestamp opens that moment on YouTube.
Read the full transcript 9,144 words
0:00 Welcome to the Tesla Pod, Duane. All right. Super excited for this. Right. Right. Right. Right. So this car it is driving on a system, right? That initially when it was introduced, right, it made a lot of people uncomfortable, right? And you spent multiple decades inside financial institut in institutions, right? Seeing this happening over and over again, right? different systems being like an implemented and people are uncomfortable at it initially, right? And then that essentially becomes a norm right so does this really feel familiar to you? It totally does. I'm thinking of like one of the first examples I had is or one example that stands out was the cloud back 2009 2010 in banking the idea of using the cloud was very foreign. Everybody was building very large data centers and I was working at HSBC at the time and we had like multiple data centers that were massive investments and infrastructure and the idea of using the cloud to run your compute and data was just so foreign.
1:07 The idea was it was too much risk. The banks had to control the assets or security all that kind of thing. And then that was like 2009 give or take. And then there were a few early adopters. I think Capital One was one of the first banks to do it. And then within about a year or two, it went from like nobody using it and thinking it was never going to be feasible for banks to run all their private data on public infrastructure to like two years later everybody was doing it. And today I can't imagine a CTO that's not heavily embedded on, you know, cloud infrastructure. Yeah. I can't I assume there may be a few banks that still have data centers, but there must be very few. You've seen this happening over and over again, right? So, what's the 30 seconds version of warrant, right? And then what is it? And then who is it that you're building this for? Yeah. well, warrant as in stock warrant or the warrant infrastructure that make it easier to use warrants because they're a tool that can allow better growth and better alignment between companies. So employees have stock options and companies use stock options for employees. For investors, you use equity, you use shares. But for commercial partners, outside partners,
2:26 The stock warrant is a tool and it allows an early stage company to share a little upside with the community of partners that they're working with. And it helps by letting the partners share in the upside of the companies they're working with. And so a stock warrant is very simply it's very similar to an option. It allows a company to be able to buy shares in the future at a price that's set today. Yeah. I think I mean the lot of lot of larger companies of course like you know they are exercising this right but for startups like I mean what we are usually used for is safe. It's a standard term right? Then stock options that's also a standard term right but warrant right you know from the initial getgo right a lot of startup founders specifically speaking like you know I don't think they are familiar with the term you know that we are able to use this right but then when I really dive deep into like you know what you're trying to bring in that you're trying to really make warrants like you know really mainstream right and but like you know say what is the I mean why don't you first of all explain what a warrant is right because some of our listeners like you know they don't exactly I mean we've heard of it right but it would be helpful for us
3:44 To understand what is a warrant right and then how can we use a warrant yeah so the simplest way is just think of a stock option it's the it's the right to buy the shares in the future at today's price but unlike a stock option which is generally structured around an employee program is designed for an employee a stock warrant is the right to buy the shares that you can grant to a company. It's a standalone agreement. And what that means is that it often has very specific terms that can allow for alignment. So normal stock option is just going to vest based on time in service and everybody in the plan has the same general stock option. Whereas with a stock warrant, it may have terms that are very specific to the commercial relationship that you have. So often it may have performance vesting where it only vests if certain milestones are achieved but those milestones may be growth or delivery of a service or delivery of a platform or a supply and also one so that performance is a very important distinction and then often a stock warrant is often there for the very like up to like 10 years. So you may have the vesting occur when a
5:02 Certain right when the performance is met, but the actual warrant may sit for you often will have like a seven or 10 year lifespan on that warrant so that it can be aligned to the founders's objectives so that you're really sharing a little bit of upside with the partners that are helping you build the business. Right. And one of the recent mega warrant deal that was done, right? It was it's with OpenAI and AMD, right? Yeah, which is a very interesting like you know case that I read up, right? Why don't you explain about it context and just be real clear like warrants have been around for a really long time. They the idea of like sharing a little bit upside with the companies that help you grow has been there, but they're generally complicated and they can be poorly misunderstood and they can be poorly used. But so they've been around for a long time, but they're often restricted to being used by larger companies where they have a lot of support from a legal technical tax kind of point of view to make them happen. And that's what we're trying to make easier. The example of the examples we're seeing today are like Google working with Marvell. So I believe on that example the warrant was granted from Marvell to Google and Google was buying I believe it was chips
6:20 For on that example was buying product on a certain volume of chips. So what happens is Marvell who's providing supply is giving Google a little bit of upside in that agreement. So they're going to share if they if Google actually buys the $8 billion. I forget the exact terms of that deal, but I think it was like an $8 billion order over a long period of time. And they might have had tranches. So every $500 million or whatever large purchases Google makes and that supply will give them a little upside in Marvell. And that really helps both sides because it's helping Marvell secure a very important foundational partner and they'll understand here's a demand and what they you know they have this great customer now and it's really helping Google because Google is also then having some skin in the game.
7:16 They're sharing some upside for the value that they're creating at Marvell. So it's a win for both sides and the warrant is the instrument that lets that happen in a way that can do that right. And why do you think Duane right so for early stage startups I mean one of the things that you're trying to advocate also like how can early stage startups like start to adopt warrants as well right why do you think I mean just as like I mean safe it's a of course a simple mechanism right so but it's very widely adopted right so of course like you know there's a risk angle to this as well for sure right but what's the main reason that you think that early stage startup founders they have not really adopted this. Is it because they're not educated about it or people are not really like you know open to exercising borrowance at this stage? Yeah, it's a it's a couple of things. I think there hasn't been infrastructure for it but I would go back to the analogy right when I started out stock options were exotic. So I've got a little bit of gray hair and back at the time stock options were not common, right? They were very restricted. they were limited kind of instruments and about you know 20 some years ago they become much more common and today I don't think there's a startup that isn't issuing stock options to early employees and there isn't a an
8:33 Employee that goes to work at a startup that doesn't expect to share in some upside and have some alignment and they they acknowledge they're going to get maybe a little bit less cash compensation for that. So that's been normalized and then about 12 years ago the safe note was introduced by YC and that became very common and now everybody's using safe notes for the main equity and that really solves a problem. warrants I think are just a little bit more complicated in that each one is essentially a standalone equity agreement and so there's a lot of considerations have to be thought through around what happens you know a the legal structure what securities exemption and what kind of requirements do you have to issue this equity or this right to the equity and then you have considerations for tax and accounting and conditional situations around what happens if there's a merger and acquisition what happens for the information rights what happens on various terms. We are working very hard to seek more standardization on those terms. We often we have a library of model agreements that are based on very best practices and common industry conventions and so we can really guide firms into the structure that works for their situation and their objectives and the tax legal accounting considerations they have. So
9:53 I think the reason startups often don't use these is they're typically rather difficult if you just start from scratch and there hasn't really been a catalyst. has been the technology is that aside from suppliers as well right I mean from a vendor right the openness should come from the vendor side as well in order for this to be successful because like they need to acknowledge on the fact that right if it's an early stage startup it's high risk right but of course high reward right but because of I mean is that that risk averseness right do you think that's also playing a role on why this has not really been highly adopted yeah I mean I think If a company works with startups on a regular basis, taking warrants makes a ton of sense because if you are working with early stage companies, as we all know, they don't all work out. So there's a high what I'd call churn, right? So if you're working with startups and you only go after cash price, what happens is the cash price for the service gets pushed higher because you have to offset the cost of the churn to compensate for like the it's factored into the pricing, right? Which constrains them. higher price is going to be less demand. It's constraining the deal value. And so you know that kind of taking of a warrant then allows the startup to share a little bit of the upside that can complement the cash
11:14 That's in the price or you know make the make the deal sweetener. You know many people think of a warrant as a sweetener. It sweetens the deal. And so companies that take warrants on a regular basis have found that they can be a very effective strategy. Right. So I had worked at Silicon Valley Bank and many of my colleagues had and at SVB the company was able to take warrants and this is in their public record. They took warrants for over 20 years and it offset all credit losses over that period of time for the book of business that they had. So what that meant was fundamentally the bank was able to provide the banking services and products on better terms that was more founder friendly but it allowed so it allowed them to serve the market in a way that the startups were getting a better service and that's the that's the beauty of the warrant and I think that they don't get used by founders as often is just because it's hard to initiate how do you determine who's going to accept a warrant and if you're going to accept a warrant a typical startup doesn't have an attorney, an accountant, and an investment banker to kind of put the deal together. And they don't have the insight on what's market, what are the actual terms and mechanics that work for their situation. And that's what we've set up to solve. Right. Right. Right. And your tagline it is innovation deserves better.
12:36 Yeah. Better than what? Yeah. I mean ultimately we think way too many deals don't use stock warrants right that should be we think it would be you know the that in many cases key deals are constrained by the cash price so if you're work if a startup's involved if you're working with startups the pricing is not sharing in the upside for the value and contribution so it's either pushing the price up which is maybe constraining the deal and if you're the startup you may not be winning your own description, right? It says that these modern programs, right? They run on run as one of legal events, right? And then multiple PDFs and then these spreadsheets, right? They are being reconstructed even at the time of the audit, right? So, what does a bad warrant program really look like, right? And how does like you know, one of these bad programs look like this inside an institution? Yeah. So warrants work, using them doesn't, right? Like the like the instrument itself has tons of evidence on the value being created and there's, you know, lots of examples of warrants that really created value for both sides. but using them doesn't because historically in order to
13:52 Initiate a warrant, there had to be like the commercial catalyst. which is typically going to take somebody to start to put the deal on the table. And then you have to have the wherewithal to bring together a very complicated team of lawyers, accountants, tax people, commercial minds, and the operational people together to put the warrant. And you have to do that on both the company that's issuing the warrant, but also on the holding company. They have to think about how they're going to manage that warrant. Because even though a smart team is often brought together to do the warrant, that team's usually moved on over the life of the 7 to 10 years that a warrant may exist because usually a warrant has a very long expiration date. And so typically the way these have been done historically is it's a PDF or a word document has a lot of red lines. It goes by email back and forth between a number of counterparties and then it gets executed and filed in PDFs. the company that holds that warrant has obligations over time. If they have shareholders or partners or they have regulatory stakeholders, they have to be able to record and report on the value of those positions over time. They may have rights and terms within the warrant that really matter. There could be information rights, there could be exercise rights, what happens if there's another capital raise or strategic action. All those kind of things could happen over this long lifespan. So a warrant is put together in a quarter
15:13 But then is going to maybe live for 10 years maybe across funds maybe across employees across like you know a pretty long period of time and so a lot of value is lost and so warrants work but using them doesn't and a lot of the value is lost in the management cycle. So we constantly hear of stories of firms where they've had warrants that didn't get exercised in the worst case. They missed the upside or the rights. they have had challenges when they have audits where they have to be able to report on the value of their positions. firms that have missed out on actions that they could have taken to optimize their tax and value from the warrant or investment committees or oversight committees that they know they have a position in a warrant that was maybe taken six years ago, but they don't have the visibility into exactly what that warrant is today at their at their fingertips. And so generally most firms that have issued or taken warrants have done it bespoke oneoff and it sits in spreadsheets and you know isolated files as opposed to being managed as a true instit as a true asset that deserves proper governance and management and that's why we built the platform. Right. And what is the I mean can if you
16:32 Can walk me through the life cycle of how this works right from term sheet right and then all the way through the execution right so how does it work right and what's the stage that you really think that it breaks right now in the current procedure yeah so it brings it a couple places and real simply and I'll take it from like the founders perspective although we often work with the holders the enterprises the banks that work with startups accept award as part of the as part of the agreement. But taking it from the founders's perspective, typically they're going to run into a warrant the first time they reach venture debt. Perhaps we'll almost always be asking for a warrant or at an early equity round, they may be asked to issue a warrant. Typically, they don't have much experience, but they that's usually the start is the initiation of the warrant. And that is going to begin with the drafting of the term sheet and the terms for that warrant. It may be together with the other commercial deal or a broader commercial agreement. So perhaps there's some other commercial agreement and now we're into the negotiation and the consideration will in will develop the warrant. So we think of that as basically the initiation and structuring phase where it's determining what are the terms that are going to be offered, what are the terms that going to be agreed upon, how are they going to be measured and trying to take into account what are the possibilities over that need to be taken into this agreement. And so that's the initiation of the warrant. Then there's normally the so the term
17:55 Sheet is usually going to agree on the broad commercial considerations and then there's the execution of that warrant into the detail of a contract that then is counter assigned. So that you can think of as then the execution. So the there's the drafting of that agreement and the exchange with the counterparty and their adviserss for the finalization of that agreement. Once that's finalized, there's actually a contract now that's been entered between the two companies and we register that into the platform. So now we have a registered transaction and then that's going to exist until it either expires or is exercised and over that period of time which could be any you know could be any period of time maybe somebody's going to have an a very quick exit and then you know that will happen but often most startups are going to have many years until there's an actual the liquidity event or the exit or the M&A that may happen and so over that period of time there's the management of that portfolio in that warrant. And so there's often then during that period there may be quarterly valuations or annual valuations. There might be information rights that need to be provided. So what we think of that is just the management of that warrant. That's mostly on the side of the holder.
19:06 The founder and the issuer generally just has some obligations often to provide insight on their financials, any material actions. They have some obligations to the is to the holder of the warrant to stay informed. and the holder if they've met the performance obligations for the vesting then has the right to exercise that warrant based on whatever conditions were agreed upon. So, it can get a little complicated. We try very hard to make that simpler, but you basically have the initial deal structuring and development of the deal, the drafting of the actual warrant, the execution of the warrant, then you have the long life cycle of the warrant. And then once the warrant exists, there may not be a lot that happens for an extended period of time. Maybe there's just some information to make so the holder understands the value of the warrant and can manage it properly for their accounting and their shareholder obligations. but then eventually there's going to be some hopefully there's going to be an outcome an exit and then there's going to be the exercise of that warrant and that then can also turn into how does the holder want to exercise? Are they going to exercise all the shares you know exercise the warrant into shares and they're going to exercise th those shares or not? So there's then that the the life cycle at the end which is you know resolving the actual warrant. So two pieces that caught my eye was okay there's from one side there's legal administrative side
20:27 Of it right and there's an accounting angle to it as well right so is it 50/50 or is it more to do with legal and less to do with accounting what's the weightage like yeah it's really great question and we often think of it that we think it's a couple groups and I don't think it's 50/50 it's probably maybe 3030 and maybe 40 I don't another a couple groups, right? So, you have your the legal team is definitely going to be involved. we're not a law firm, but we do have our own lawyers. We have a lot of legal expertise and we have a lot of the standard terms. So, we can make it much easier for the to get to the agreement and we can support the attorney so they can do the job much more efficiently to review that. the the accounting team also has the implications on the tax accounting as well as just the financial administration of the warrant. and so that is going to be involved but then there's also the commercial considerations of what's the structure what's the right terms that you want to use the mechanics because there's mechanics around just even things around you know the governance law information rights these kind of things that are just need to be pinned down and those are typically just the commercial deal terms that we guide our clients on. Right. Right. the main skepticism right that runs in I think a lot of people who hear this the first time right especially a startup right I
21:51 Mean Carter right is a widely known like you know cap tableable management tool right so they have the option which like you know we could manage borons there as well right so of course like you know from what I understood it's more of just a simple feature right but I think in your what warrant what your company does right it provides a complete infrastructure to us that did I get the distinction right so how does this really differentiate from being just a simple feature in a cap table management tool right versus like you know actual like where you're really building a company around this right yeah we are complimentary to something like a card or cap table so the cap table is the connect cart straight away. Yeah. Or I mean it's it depends on the connections to your to your cap table provider but we can provide the outputs that you need for your cap table management can integrate to those that have open connectors. but essentially that's the after the-act record of your equity cap table, but the warrant is the instrument and what we think of ourselves as the horizontal layer. That's actually the facilitation transaction layer for these
23:09 Transactions. So that's what we do and cap table management is basically going to be the record of the transaction that you have. So they'll record the existence of a warrant or a share or an option that you may have granted. we're actually facilitating the transaction and then the activity on the long life cycle around that because the warrant goes much further than just how many shares would be granted to whom on what expiration date. There's many there's much more to that. I see. Okay. And what is it in warrant that does not do yet? Right. that you want to actually make it happen.
23:49 Yeah. The biggest thing that we're working on is continue to just make these transactions easier just by this conversation. it's a comp it can be a complicated instrument and the conceptually it's quite simple. You're sharing some upside so things work out the partners that are helping you build the business can share on the contribution and the value that they helped create. Right? the concept has been around. I'm sure for farmers like thousands of years ago were probably sharing upside with people who helped them with the harvest, right? So wars have been around. but there's a lot of implications that come in to all the contingencies. How do you want to do the performance vesting? How much dilution is it is appropriate for the transaction value that you're gaining? all these kind of complexities that can come into that. What we've been working on is continuing to just try to make that simpler and easier. So really moving towards much more consistent model legal documents so that just like before credit card transactions you know it would be very difficult to do a card transaction without the infrastructure of all the you know all the terms and conditions that are in your credit card agreement right that had to be put in place to make it easy for you just use Visa Mastercard to do
25:05 Transactions there's a lot of plumbing underneath Visa and Mastercard that makes it easy to just open a credit card and do that transaction and warrants are kind of the same way where there's a fair amount that needs to be taken into account to make it easier for clients to be able to issue a warrant or accept the warrant and manage it. And what we're continuing to do is just try to make that easier to standardize a lot of the common we'd like to see more consistent model legal agreements across the industry for warrants just like the YC safe note unlocked, you know, massive improvements in the ability to capitalize and grow innovative companies through the Safe Note. We believe that more normalized standardized stock warrant agreements will do the same thing to introduce something. We are we are very much we've already built we already have built like model legal agreements for warrants that are in our library that are based on very conventional industry standards. I mean the majority of the banking warrants probably more than half are based on Silicon Valley bank paper historically if you look at it like the m the basic structure in terms. So the basic mechanisms of warrants are quite clear and consistent. there are best practices but there are going to be some areas where it you know it really needs some variation around you know what are the commercial terms what's the strike price how many years are you going to
26:23 Invest so there's a couple of things that need to be determined client by client for the for their context so what we're trying to do is simplify as much of that so we can lower the boundaries or the barriers to using a warrant or accepting a warrant so that this can be done more easily and we think that helps founders because then founders can you know They can win partnerships, they can win distribution, they can they can share another form of currency that they aren't using today. And warren have existed now for over decades, right? So why has nobody really built this before? And why do you think that this is the moment to build this? well, I think like startups are getting leaner and smaller, which is one thing, right? So they're more dependent on their ecosystem than ever. so as you're more dependent on your ecosystem that puts more emphasis on partnerships and the other companies that are helping you build your community which is driving the need for warrants and then the complexity was really hard to manage and we're obviously an AI native company building the platform around very complicated topics and a lot of training on transactions and historical performance and experience so that we can embed that into the platform to make this accessible. So like warrants have been around and they're getting done
27:40 Historically, but the cost of doing a warrant transaction is often very high and it's prohibitive for early stage companies or those companies that take warrants are often not going to use them because of the friction and the cost. So they just don't get used. And then again that brings us back to people missing out on the value of better partnerships and you know equity aligned agreements. Right. Right. And you actually advised the Silicon Valley bank from 2016 to 2019, right? And SVB was literally right, you know, literally the bank right now that was holding enormous amounts of like, you know, borance, right? To for venture lending, right? So, what did you see there right so at your time at like an SVB specifically, right? Why did you see there that there is a real dysfunctionality over in the way how this really been operated right that led you to like you know build on this opportunity. Yeah. So and then put that in context like SVB was great. I was a fan continue to be a fan of many aspects of the company and how they operate. They were very founder friendly very focused on how to help grow the ecosystem and I had
29:00 A chance to see that and it was unfortunate what happened. which had I would argue nothing to do with the warrant program or portfolio. there you know there were there were decisions around treasury management and the diversification of the bank and other risk management failures that occurred. but the warrant program essentially allowed the bank to offer more competitive products and services and value to their clients by accepting a warrant as part of the relationship. And that gave them a little skin in the game. but it also gave the founders the better service and products and pricing that they gained from that and it was very successful a very large number of startups over a long period of time granted warrants to SVB but even then so we knew the value of warrants we saw the performance we saw the outcomes how it really served both sides but we knew that it was very operationally difficult I've seen it from multiple sides I've seen it from the bank side of taking the warrants where it was difficult costly to manage hard to comply with there was generally manual processes and fragmented data around challenges of managing the warrant. And if you're a founder who's issuing a warrant, it's actually quite difficult to grant that. You're often going to run into it the first time. And typically, it's coming when you're closing equity and you're closing around
30:20 And then you're adding venture debt on top of that or some other meaningful transaction. And as a founder, you're trying to build your business and grow. and now you're being introduced with a warrant on top of whatever other agreements you have. So, it's hard to really have the there's an asymmetrical understanding of how warrants work and the expertise on that. And so, that really led to us and you know, while I was at SVB, I we just saw that it worked and we knew it was a really hidden jewel within the bank's business and how they operated. And we really questioned why warrants were restricted to only really big ticket transactions. So you typically see warrants heavily on venture debt. Almost most venture debt comes with a warrant request. You'll see it on large corporate joint corporate venture you know joint venture transactions will often have a warrant and those are and then you'll see them sometimes on very early stage the simplest of types of transaction. And when we looked at that, what we really realized is that warrants are used pretty consistently with companies that are working with startups on large multi-million dollar transactions on a regular basis where the legal tax accounting fees are overcome because they see the value in the warrant and they use it. But capital
31:38 Is only one of the sources that startups need. Startups are raising capital and using capital, but they're using it significantly for suppliers, customers, distributors, you know, all these other activities, services that they need. And if you can use the warrant, then you can be more efficient with the cash. Right. Right. And what is the most u interesting non-bank use of warrant that you have come across? One of the ones great is we've been we've we looked at one with Arnold Schwarzenegger and so the Terminator will be back. He'll be back when the strike price is right. You spoken to him? Yeah. No, we haven't spoken with Arnold but he did work on a warrant through his genius brands cartoons and it was basically taking accepting upside for his likeness and image in certain types of contribution to a media event. not event but you know production and so it showed like the mechanics of talent you know taking a warrant as part of a talent transaction so that kind of struck with us because you know big fan of some of Arnold's movies and seeing him take a warrant on a transaction that wasn't tied to capital it was tied to sharing upside because
32:59 Obviously he was contributing to this project and he was being rewarded by the right to buy shares and the outcome if it was successful and sharing in that right it's awesome so shifting gears now to the founder journey right so you started at MBANA in 1989 you were one of the founding members of MBNA international UK and then the first on-site employee at MBNA Canada right what does like you know first on-site day on-site employee actually mean and like you know practically what does it look like on day well I mean that was early days of fintech we didn't even have the term fintech but the credit card businesses were I mean it was at the time one of the largest credit card companies and is now a big part of the bank of America portfolio but being the first employee went meant literally we showing up in Ottawa Canada and getting the keys from an office space that we leased we didn't have wei works at the time And we had, you know, going up in advance and, you know, securing some of the facilities, but literally we had yellow pages in those days and opening it up and ordering some equipment beginning some activities
34:17 And then just opening the doors and then I had a team of other folks that we were working with as a group to fully open the bank. I was the yeah the COO and it was it was one of the very it was the first credit card monoline kind of player in Canada and we worked with the National Hockey League major league sports a lot of the universities and professional associations were one of the first companies to do affinity type of card issuance in Canada. Right. Right. And from there you moved to then one of the places that you worked at is Providian right? So Providian you were there at a very interesting time from 98 to 2002 right so through the growth of like you know 35 billion assets and then in your own words you mentioned correction through the corrections as well right so that's a very diplomatic term at that time but what exactly happened and what do you see yeah it was fantastic I mean it was a really interesting journey learned a ton always learning and great people we were here in San Francisco on to mission we had become the second largest visa issuer at the time in the country. I think we were the second largest Visa issuer on total volume and we we learn we grew very fast. We were a specialty credit card issuer very data
35:35 Driven very early use of analytics and high you know high signal and test and learning to be able to identify segments and the right offer for the right customer at the right point in time. but the company grew too fast. I had joined to help build a lot of the infrastructure for credit and technology and we scaled very quickly and then there was a there were some challenges that came up with the after 9/11 and we didn't have the growth we didn't have all the controls in place that we needed and then ultimately the company sold and became part of what's now JP Morgan. Hm. Was there I mean this around the time the.com bubble as well, right? That's right. We came through the dotcom bubble. I think we had out at the time I think I heard that we had outperformed Microsoft for like several years in a row. We were the number one S&P financial stock. but we' grown way I don't say grew too fast but we grew incredibly fast. I don't think we had all the tools and infrastructure like operating infrastructure that you need to manage growth in a sustainable way.
36:41 And that caught up to us in a variety of operating problems and then eventually some credit problems that then required you know a downsizing of the company and then the sale. Right. Right. And then you moved to HSBC and there you ended up being the America's head of global risk data and technology and regional CEO for risks risk and compliance. Right. Quite a big title, right? Why did you even big bank big titles they kind of go sometimes go together. I started at HSBC essentially as I think that we didn't have the title at the time but it was I was essentially the chief information officer chief technology officer for the credit card business part of the executive team oversaw the technology team that supported the card business that we had in the US and it was a terrific business. We had private label cards, credit cards and then I, transitioned from that after several years. after the financial crisis, the bank had to consolidate, had to restructure many things that came out, following the financial crisis. And they asked me to take a role as a chief operating officer for the risk and compliance functions of
37:58 The bank. And that was largely helping strengthen the bank's risk management programs, its operating infrastructure as it adjusted to the post financial crisis. and so I worked through all of that, but part of that was also managing all the data and the infrastructure for risk decisioning and credit decisioning and the retail banking business. And so that just continued to build on my experience on working with what we know we didn't think of it as AI at the time but the early days of machine learning large data lakes data science types of capabilities and you know continue to work with that up through today right so compliance when you speak about compliance it is treated as the enemy of innovation in this now right so you've been on both these sides right so who is right I don't see it really as like a who is right I think I view compliance as a design constraint that needs to be properly understood and fully understood I think often sometimes people who haven't been close to it may not fully understand
39:14 The significance of compliance requirements u or risk management obligations so I think it just becomes a design concern. So I think innovation and innovation firms can be very effective if they bring that same mindset to their risk and compliance obligations, right? Like I think of I don't know some of the folks when they first turned out with like authentication and being able to move to being able to do compliance in a much more seamless way to verify know your customer types of obligations, right? making that can be an innovative way to make it easier for your customers to verify who they are for their transactions and be compliant with knowing your customer which is a you know banking regulation. whereas like sometimes companies that may not understand that pay lip service to it short change the compliance obligations and ultimately that doesn't work out in the long run. Right. And then you moved on to co-founding tribal credit raised close to 140 million right so from soft bank QD and then others then you raised it to 5,000 plus clients and over billion in crossber volume right so that's quite a journey and then you it was acquired by CLA as well right so how I mean why don't you tell about this journey and what would
40:36 You do different if you were to untribal once again. Right. Right. So, I was at Silicon Valley Bank for somewhere as a HSBC. I then went at for like 11 years and spent a couple years at Silicon Valley Bank and I was really working on the founders platform early stage product working with early stage credit strategies and product strategies to help serve startups. And that's where I got much more deeply involved in the startup ecosystem. And then I was introduced to my co-founder through my work at Silicon Valley Bank because we had built out the scoring algorithms that were used to rank order early stage startups and that was used for like underwriting for a long period of time. And when we launched tribal we knew there was a gap in terms of being able to serve startups effectively with credit payment and other banking products and services. And we thought that we saw that problem in the US, but we also saw it globally and we built tribal to bring that to a more global marketplace. And we grew it was a we achieved a lot. We achieved those kind of statistics. served thousands of customers, had terrific NPS scores. Customers really loved what we did and how we operated. but the company required capital to scale and we were unable to build that scale that we needed to make that work. And so that led to you know the sale to clar who
41:57 Had that ability to carry that forward. So learned that the community around it really matters and having alignment with the capital partners and having that in place was really essential and ultimately there was a period of time where the this the scale that we needed we couldn't achieve right I mean with all these experience right and then with all these successes that you've like you know built with the previous companies as well right most of people would have retired by now right so but you started another company right what you are building right now in 2025 instead. Why? Yeah, I am. Well, personally, I'm it's a little bit my personality. I'm curious. I still I'm excited by what I'm trying to do, but I think this problem found me. I was captivated by looking at the examples of warrants being used in so many cases where there were really great outcomes, but in very limited ways. And the problem kind of found me in the sense that we couldn't really find a satisfactory answer as to why warrants you were not being used more broadly. And the answer that we came to was ultimately that there just hasn't been a catalyst. the
43:16 Difficulty and the complexity hadn't been eliminated and made easier and it just restricted the use of warrants to large parties with very large legal teams and budgets and we knew that we could make this easier. And so the more we kept working on that and talking with founders and talking to the companies that take warrants and realizing that even those companies who use warrants didn't have the didn't have the tools to do it very effectively we knew that we could make this easier and better and that's been driving us cuz we like the companies we work with. We like the founders we work with and it kind of gets me out of bed each day and right keeps me excited. Right. Right. So moving on to some hot takes. Right. So everyone they say that AI will transform underwriting. You were doing AI powered underwriting at tribal years ago, right? Where even before the whole AI wave has really become mainstream, right?
44:12 Is this current wave different or is it the same thing with beta marketing? I believe it's fundamentally different. I have heard that push back. I have seen what was early AI was probably one of the earliest people to deploy neural network models in fraud detection and credit card underwriting going back many years to some of the very earliest neural network models. because credit cards is one of the places where you had large data sets that you could really that and stock markets were two places where you could really use advanced optimization and models to perform. And so anyway, I've seen it for a long time. I believe it is fundamentally different. I think the scale, capacity, rate, the is beyond what we've seen before. And I think so I think that actual way underwriting is being done will change. It'll probably take some time to get the guard rails right to get the compliance and the confidence and the explanability correct. so I think it's going to change from the inside within banks and financial institutions where they will be using positioning differently but I also think that the macro economy is changing around this too where I'm
45:29 Just thinking about like Metamuse coming out the other day and how the story in the Wall Street Journal today is whether sleepy banks are going to be in trouble because Metamuse may just immediately solve all the small pennies that are in accounts that aren't being used properly, right? like it'll be able to opt a agentic kind of tooling for everyone is probably going to optimize all kinds of financial decisions and so I think the way payments get done the way transactions get done will be much more agentic and AI enabled in the future and so I think that's also going to change the game so I'm a pretty big believer that the change is real and it's fundamentally different and more advanced than we've seen before right so something that we both share right is that right your whole career it's been about predicting how people and companies they will behave before it actually before they actually behave right there's like you know credit models risk decisioning underwriting right and then well we used to call it behavioral scoring right that was the name of the actual industry name is behavioral scoring I see right so what we are building at market tricks is like you know we build this like you know database of like 200 159 million odd personas right representing every working individual every consumer in the
46:50 Adult consumer of the US right and we build these like you know persona so that you could run simulations against products against pricing decisions right so that's a model like you know that we are building right so then we both we are betting that a model of a person it is actually useful enough right for before it actual acts on it, right? So, in your opinion, where does this breakdown, right? And how do you know when to stop trusting a model? Wow, big question. We may need a couple red lights to get through this one. I think we're I think it's brilliant, by the way. I think it's an very interesting idea. And we've and there have been, you know, you're building on like things that have come before, right? Because there has been what we would think of as and you may know this like the credit bureaus and like Axiom and companies like that have often had scored the entire universe and then you might have like pre-screened decisions of one when you walk into a merchant. They may already, if you apply, they already know and have that offer waiting for you because they pre-screened against, you know, a universe of all consumers. But often that's on like a defined narrow data set of like credit bureau
48:08 Data or something like that. And your ability to do that more broadly across all these different dimensions and then have a profile of one for each consumer is interesting. My sense is that where it breaks is confidence and the explanability, the governance around how that data is used, what's considered privacy. that would be my sense as to where you'll run into challenges. I think you can probably get a build the profiles and you can build the be the predictors pretty effectively. But then you know in traditional credit scoring and credit decisioning there's often safeguards around who has access to that data, how it can be used, how you avoid bias and adverse actions if things of that nature. So the in how the insight gets used will probably raise Is it to do with having as much as context as possible? Is that what's going to make the model better in your opinion? Yeah, I think usually more data is always better. but you but you do see issues and you know you have seen issues in the past where models maybe are picking up bias that is not intentional
49:26 But that bias is something that we would not find acceptable as you know an action. Do you know what I mean? like it may pick up an historical bias in the data or the context that you don't want to be deployed. So I think the application of that context and the management of that context will take probably time to refine and figure out the right norms and frameworks to apply it. I see. Right. So if there's someone in their 50s right now, right, who is sitting at a bank, right, and at a very senior role, right, who has an idea, right, but who's already decided that they're too late, right, to execute on this idea. What would you tell them?
50:12 I would say you're never too late, right? I personally still feel very energized. I love, you know, I'm my co-founders. because I have some brilliant co-founders who are way smarter than I am. They're young. They energize, you know, I get a lot of energy out of just working with them and seeing their insight and thoughts. so I think if you have an idea that really motivates you, I think the world is like much more open to that than it's ever been in terms of the tooling, the infrastructure, the innovation economies. Like there's a lot of support that just didn't exist 10, 20, 30 years ago. And so somebody who's senior already later in the career has a lot of experience and expertise and I wouldn't hold that against someone I mean I do go to a lot of events where most of the other founders and like Llama Lounge are probably in their 20s. I'm at the other end where I seen a lot over 30 years and I think there's a there's something to be said for both sides of that relationship. And I think if being a founder is not easy, it's hard. It's sometimes I ask myself like you know is this you know what should I get myself into but you know if you believe in something and you think it's
51:28 The right thing to do sometimes at the tail end of your career is a great way to do it too right this has been such a wonderful chat doing right where do people find you and warrant yeah so very simply wrt.co warrant.co is probably the easiest place to learn more. We have a lot of insight. We have a lot of tools available, a lot of you know continuous information. So that's a great resource. I'm also on LinkedIn at Duane Good on LinkedIn and those are probably the best couple of sources. We're also on X and yeah and they can always reach out. Love to talk to people about growth and rewards. Awesome. So thanks a lot Duane and stay tuned till the next episode of Tesla Bot. Thank you.